The Reserved List
A promise from Wizards of the Coast that certain cards will never be reprinted — and the reason a fixed pool of 1990s cardboard behaves like a scarce asset class.
Top Pick
Black Lotus
Limited Edition Alpha
Five to six figures
Ranked by market value
The most valuable Reserved List card and a Power Nine artifact. Permanent scarcity plus icon status keeps it at the top.
The priciest Reserved List land outside the Power Nine. A brutal creature tax that Legacy and Commander players prize, from the low-print-run Legends set.
Taps for green equal to your creatures — the mana engine of green go-wide decks across eternal formats.
A counterspell that ramps. The original Legends copy is Reserved List and carries a heavy old-border premium.
The most played of the ten original dual lands. Every ABUR dual is Reserved List, so demand from Legacy and Commander never meets fresh supply.
A powerful mana rock for combo decks. Reserved List status keeps this artifact well above what its rarity alone would suggest.
A one-mana tutor from one of the scarcest English sets ever released, compounding Reserved List scarcity with genuine print rarity.
The heart of artifact-ramp combo decks. A niche card whose Reserved List lock makes it far pricier than its play rate implies.
Once a joke, now a Legacy storm engine. A textbook case of Reserved List scarcity meeting rediscovered combo value.
What Is the Reserved List?
The Reserved List is a set of cards, mostly from 1994 and earlier, that Wizards of the Coast has publicly committed to never reprinting in a tournament-legal form. It was created in 1996 to reassure collectors after early reprint sets angered the community. Because the list can only ever shrink through damage and loss, these cards have a permanently fixed supply, which is the primary driver of their long-term prices.
Why Reserved List Cards Hold Value
Ordinary Magic cards can crash overnight when Wizards reprints them in a Commander deck or Masters set. Reserved List cards are immune to that risk, so buyers treat them as scarce collectibles rather than replaceable playing pieces. The most valuable ones combine three traits: eternal-format playability, iconic history, and demand from the enormous Commander player base. Dual lands are the clearest example — nearly every serious Legacy or Commander deck wants them, and none will ever be reprinted.
Checking Reserved List Prices
Reserved List values drift with collector demand and can jump on speculation, so a recent estimate matters. Scan any card with Tappr to confirm the exact printing and finish and pull TCGplayer and Cardmarket market estimates. It is an easy way to find out whether the old rares in a binder are quietly Reserved List cards worth real money.
Common questions
01 What does Reserved List mean in Magic?
It is an official list of cards Wizards of the Coast has promised never to reprint in a tournament-legal frame. Cards on it include the Power Nine, the original dual lands, and many other 1990s staples.
02 Why are Reserved List cards so expensive?
Their supply is permanently fixed — no reprints will ever be made — while demand from Legacy, Vintage, and especially Commander keeps growing. Scarcity plus steady demand pushes prices up over time.
03 Will Wizards ever abolish the Reserved List?
Wizards has repeatedly reaffirmed the list and shows no sign of removing cards from it. Any change would be highly controversial, and for now buyers price these cards as though they will never be reprinted.
04 How do I know if a card is on the Reserved List?
The list is published and fixed. Scanning a card with Tappr identifies the exact printing, and Reserved List cards tend to show much higher, more stable prices than their reprinted counterparts.
Related price guides
Check your cards' value
Tappr identifies a Magic card and shows a Scryfall market estimate synced about every 24 hours.
No credit card. No signup. Just scan.
Scan to download
Point your phone camera at a code
- Free on iOS & Android
- No account required