Deck building on the web vs scanning cardboard in your hands
Archidekt is a popular Commander deck-building platform. Tappr does not replace deck builders — it scans physical cards for identity, market estimate, and collection tracking.
Feature Comparison
See how Tappr stacks up against Archidekt.
| Feature | Tappr | Archidekt |
|---|---|---|
| AI Card Scanning | Yes | No |
| Market estimates | Yes | Yes |
| Collection Management | Yes | Yes |
| Set Completion Tracking | Yes | No |
| Free to Use | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile App | Yes | No |
| Portfolio Value Tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Foil & Variant Pricing | Yes | Yes |
What Archidekt does well
Archidekt specializes in building, visualizing, and iterating on Commander decks in a browser. It is strong when you already know card names and want list management, categories, and deck-building UX — not when you are staring at an unlabeled shoebox.
Where Tappr is different
Tappr’s AI camera workflow exists for unknown cardboard. It identifies printings, shows market estimates, and tracks set completion. It is not a full Commander deck editor with web collaboration features.
Which one to use
Building a 100-card list? Archidekt. Cataloging the cards you own so you know what you can already brew with? Tappr. Export or re-enter staples into your builder once the collection is scanned.
Verdict
Use Archidekt (or Moxfield) to design and share Commander decks. Use Tappr when the problem is physical cards: binders, bulk, pulls, and trades. Most Commander players benefit from both categories of tool.
Common questions
01 Does Archidekt scan cards with a camera?
Archidekt is primarily a deck-building platform, not a camera-first MTG scanner like Tappr.
02 Does Tappr build Commander decks?
Tappr focuses on scanning and collection value. Pair it with Archidekt or Moxfield for deck construction.
03 How do prices differ?
Both ecosystems surface market-informed prices in different contexts. Tappr shows market estimates at scan time for the printing in your hand.
04 Is Tappr a Moxfield alternative?
Not really — Moxfield and Archidekt compete more with each other as deck builders. Tappr competes with ManaBox, Delver Lens, and Dragon Shield on scanning.
Other side-by-sides
Try Tappr — free scans to start
Get Tappr free. Identify any Magic: The Gathering card and see what it is worth in seconds.
No credit card. No signup. Just scan.
Scan to download
Point your phone camera at a code
- Free on iOS & Android
- No account required