Protect the Value, Not Just the Cards
A sleeved binder guards against scratches, but only a documented, valued inventory protects you against loss, theft, or fire. Here is how to catalogue and insure a collection.
Build a Valued Inventory
Insurance starts with proof of what you own and what it is worth. A valued inventory is a running list of your cards with the exact printing, condition, and a current market value for each. Building it by hand is tedious, which is why most collectors abandon it — but scanning cards into Tappr does the work automatically, identifying each card and attaching a live TCGplayer and Cardmarket price so your inventory stays current as the market moves. Keep the record backed up somewhere off-site or in the cloud, because an inventory that burns up with the collection is no help to an insurer.
Photograph and Scan the High-Value Cards
For your most expensive cards, go a step further than a line item. Photograph or scan each one clearly, capturing the front, the back, and any grading slab, so you have visual proof of the specific card and its condition. This documentation matters twice: it substantiates a claim if the card is lost or stolen, and it helps prove authenticity and condition if you ever sell. Store these images alongside your inventory and update them whenever a card's grade or condition changes.
Understand Your Coverage Options
Standard homeowner's and renter's policies often cover collectibles, but usually with a low sub-limit that a serious Magic collection blows past quickly. For a valuable collection, look into a scheduled rider (also called a floater) that lists specific high-value cards at agreed values, or a dedicated collectibles policy that covers the whole collection. Both require the valued inventory and documentation you have already built. Review your coverage as the collection grows — a policy sized for last year's collection may badly underinsure this year's, and under-coverage means you eat the difference on a loss.
Common questions
01 Does homeowner's insurance cover my Magic card collection?
Often partially — most policies include collectibles but cap them with a low sub-limit that a valuable collection exceeds. For meaningful coverage, add a scheduled rider for high-value cards or take out a dedicated collectibles policy, both of which require a documented, valued inventory.
02 How do I create an inventory for insurance?
List each card with its exact printing, condition, and current market value, and keep the record backed up off-site. Scanning cards into Tappr automates this — each card is identified and priced from the live market — so your inventory stays accurate without hours of manual data entry.
03 Should I photograph my expensive cards?
Yes. Capture clear images of the front, back, and any grading slab for high-value cards. This visual proof supports an insurance claim if the card is lost or stolen and helps confirm authenticity and condition when you sell.
04 What is a rider or floater policy?
A rider (or floater) is an add-on that schedules specific valuable items — like individual expensive cards — at agreed values, covering them beyond your base policy's collectibles sub-limit. It relies on your documented inventory and is the common way to properly insure high-value cards.
Related Collecting Guides
Track Your Collection
Get Tappr free. Identify any Magic: The Gathering card and see what it is worth in seconds.
No credit card. No signup. Just scan.
Scan to download
Point your phone camera at a code
